12/19/04: Where should home-school
oversight be?
Nashville's Tennessean newspaper asks this important question with an
in-depth article on homeschooling in our state and portions of the article have
been repeated in media across the state. Most homeschoolers would say that we're
doing just fine and additional oversight isn't necessary and would be a waste of
the State's already overstretched resources.. Weighing in on the
issue is Rep. Mark Maddox, a public school employee, whose attempt in 2001
to increase reporting for homeschoolers failed in a House floor vote
52 to 35.
"This state has an obligation to make sure its
citizens are educated. It would give home-school parents an extra assurance that
their children are not behind their peers. I'd want to know my children are on
an equal footing."
Parents who want this assurance have many
tests already available to them that can measure their child's progress in
relation to their peers.
Additionally, the state doesn't
issue homeschoolers diplomas now. Will they issue them when our children pass
those state tests?
Homeschoolers will be keeping a close eye
on the legislature this January.
Successes from last year
include:
Rep. Mike Turner's
bill last year to require homeschoolers to submit to the same tests that public
schoolers must take was withdrawn after much protest from homeschoolers and
their friends in the legislature.
And
last year the previous years
discrimination
against homeschoolers in the allotting of lottery scholarships
was corrected with one legislator calling it 'educational bigotry' to require
homeschoolers to score higher on SAT/ACT tests than their private and public
school peers.
You can post comments about this issue at the
Tennessean's website
here.
November 2004 Homeschoolers apply logic to Akron
Beacon Journal articles.
The Bludorns say: "We’d like to give you a few tools for explaining to your
friends, neighbors, and elected officials why using bad logic isn’t a good idea
when attacking homeschoolers." And since the ABJ quoted from the Bludorns' book
on logic, "The Fallacy Detective", they seem just the right folks to point out a
few errors.
You can read their critique of the professional's work at
their website. They also link to the original articles if you missed those.
11/24/04 HSLDA responds to ABJ articles.
HSLDA's Michael Smith responds to the homeschooling series published recently by
the Akron (OH) Beacon Journal. Among his rebuttals are that the number of
college applicants that are homeschooled is less than the average for two
reasons: 1. most homeschoolers are still between the ages of 5 and 17 years and
not eligible for college and 2. due to differing state regulations many
'homeschoolers' are reported on college applications as private schoolers.
Further Mr. Smith points out that according to the US Department of Health &
Human Services in 2002 nearly half of child abusers were teachers and daycare
providers.
Read the entire rebuttal
here.
~~~~~
4/7/04:
Hser Mary Parker of Williamson County wins state 4-H Essay
Contest.
Her article was titled "4-H: Honoring the Past... Envisioning
the Future".
"4-H was like that small seed when it started
out. With care it grew from humble beginnings into the
nationwide club it is today. We ourselves were much like that
seed when we joined 4-H. 4-H grounded us, nurtured us, gave us
the room to grow and the knowledge we would need to succeed in
life and then sent us out into the world."
You can read the rest
here.
3/28/04:
Why
does Clarksville's Smith family homeschool?
It's a lot of fun! Read the whole story, partly in Elvish, at
the
Clarksville Leaf-Chronicle.
3/24/04:
MidTn Hser Wins Spelling Bee.
Rose Van Ryckeghem won the
Tennessean Spelling Bee and fellow homeschooler Julian Calvin was the
runner up! Great work ladies! Read the details at the
Tennessean
and the
Nashville City Paper.
3/10/04:
" Should home school students and private school
students be held to the same lottery education qualifications,
as public school and GED graduates, in order to qualify for
lottery HOPE scholarships? Or, should home schoolers and private
school students be held to a higher qualifying standard, which
is the current state law?
Same qualifications for all groups: 73%
Different Qualifications 20%
Undecided 7%"
From Senator
Jerry Cooper's (D-McMinnville) annual constituent
survey as reported by the
Tullahoma News.
3/9/04:
Living History:
Knoxville's Christian Family Cooperative's live action history
fair makes the
news
"They're really excited when they have a fact,
especially if Mom and Dad don't know that fact ... to get to
tell them and feel like they get to teach their siblings and
parents a little bit about what they learned," says CFCS History
Fair Committee Co-Chair Larry Varnum.
1/20/04:
So why
do we need to test HSers?
In the face of current
legislation to require homeschoolers (and private schoolers) to pass the
public school system's gateway exams the Memphis Commercial Appeal publishes
this article.
'Home-schoolers have a distinct advantage because of the
individualized instruction they have received,' the admissions
officer for Dartmouth College said in the report.
In her new book, "Morning by Morning: How We Home-Schooled Our
African-American Sons to the Ivy League," Paula Penn-Nabrit
chronicles the steps she took to home-school her three sons
well enough to get them into Prince ton and Amherst."
Two Memphis
families, the Karimnia and Crowson, as well as long time Tennessee
homeschoolers, the Van Tols, are highlighted in this article. Susan Crowson's
quote is really excellent: "I don't teach to the tests," Crowson said. "We teach
for knowledge and life skills."
Interestingly, Memphis
Senator Roscoe Dixon is the senate sponsor of the legislation requiring
non-public students to take the very gateway tests that constituents in his
own Memphis public school system are having a hard time passing.